By Muhammd Gazali
In recent times, some viewers have described BBC Hausa journalist Madina Maishanu as “too harsh” during interviews with high-profile personalities. This perception, however, requires a clearer and more informed understanding of what professional journalism truly entails.
Madina Maishanu’s interview style reflects the core values of responsible journalism—firmness, neutrality, clarity, and accountability. When journalists engage public office holders or influential figures on serious national issues, their duty is not to entertain or appease, but to ask the questions the public deserves answers to.
Her calm facial expression, direct eye contact, and pointed questioning are not signs of hostility. Rather, they demonstrate discipline, preparation, and respect for the seriousness of the subject matter. Sensitive and consequential issues demand a serious tone. Excessive friendliness, smiles, or emotional reactions in such settings can trivialize the discussion and weaken its impact.
It is also important to note that Madina’s approach aligns with international broadcast standards, particularly those of the BBC, where professionalism and impartiality are fundamental. Asking tough questions respectfully is not an act of disrespect; it is the essence of accountability in journalism.
Often, the label of “harshness” arises when public figures are confronted with uncomfortable truths. In such cases, the issue is not the journalist’s tone, but the discomfort of scrutiny. A composed, firm interviewer helps keep the focus on facts, not personalities.
Madina Maishanu exemplifies a form of journalism that understands that respect does not mean softness, and courtesy does not require avoidance of difficult questions. Her style reinforces public confidence in journalism as a tool for truth, balance, and responsibility.
At a time when misinformation and superficial reporting are widespread, such professionalism should be understood, protected, and appreciated—not misinterpreted.
Muhammad Gazali
Former Editor, ThePath Newspaper, Sokoto.
